| Pasta and pre-boiling | Dry pasta, no pre-boil (recommends a 6-8 minute al dente quality) | Dry pasta, no pre-boil | 227g dry pasta, ideally not bronze-cut, no pre-boil | 300g dry pasta (serves 2), no pre-boil |
| Type and concentration of tomato | 1 1/8 cups tomato puree + 1 tbsp tomato paste (diluted with 3 cups water) | Passata di pomodoro + concentrated tomato paste | 283g fresh grape/cherry tomatoes, pureed and diluted with water | Tomato concentrate (dissolved in water) + half a jar of passata |
| Type of pan | Cast-iron pan (Puglian tradition) | Iron pan (pentola in ferro) | Nonstick (his recommendation) or well-seasoned cast iron | Heavy cast-iron or stainless pan (no nonstick) |
| Handling of garlic | 2 cloves (1 whole, 1 minced) | Grated garlic, cooked low and slow | 5-6 cloves, roughly chopped | 2 minced cloves, 20 seconds on high heat |
| Type and amount of chili | Red chili flakes, to taste | Red chili, generous | 2 fresh jalapeños (not chili flakes) | 1-2 thinly sliced red chilis |
| How the broth is added | Add one ladle at a time, waiting for evaporation between additions | Hot broth ladled in gradually, loosened with a wooden spoon | Added a quarter at a time, alternating evaporation and searing | Added in small amounts several times, absorbed into the pasta |
| Target level of char | Flip once it starts charring. Total cook time 20-30 minutes | Light charring once the pasta starts sticking (no time specified) | Until most moisture evaporates and the bottom noodles fry and brown | Total cook time 8-10 minutes. A black charred layer at the bottom is normal |
| Finish | Olive oil only. No cheese or black pepper | Topped with pecorino, paired with red wine (Susumaniello) | Basil folded in, served with pickled serrano chilis (no cheese) | Finishing oil, black pepper, and stracciatella cheese |
| Time required | 20-30 minutes | Not specified (the video runs about 15 minutes total) | Not specified | 8-10 minutes (pan cooking only, excluding broth prep) |
| Source check | Source verified | Source verified | Source verified | Source verified |